Sue. We said no to the service contract for the following reasons:
1. it was misrepresented as an "extended factory warranty".
2. It has a $$$ deductible for each shop visit.
3.It has many exclusions after the real Smart/MB 24 mo warranty runs out.
3. Our dealer is about 40 miles away and we can't afford the time and hassle, thus plan to train our local car repair guy to do much of the work on the Smart.
In your case I think I would consider a Honda or a Subaru if you must buy a car. Or put up with a lot of hassle working with your faraway dealer and going with the service contract.
BTW, the new Civic is a great looking car.

A2Jack