I'll be going with the OEM Rubber and the OEM carpeted mats (for summer).
I've tried to use aftermarket mats in my previous cars. I'm too anal over how it looks to be satisfied, plus fighting with them shifting around all of the time because of not being sized to fit the footwells, and the potential lack of complete protection sells me on the OEM ones.
Plus, I want the tailless sperm on my floorboard