Doesn't surprise me that your gas mileage was so drastically affected by air-conditioning.
These Smarts are not your father's (original) Volkswagons.
Yes, they do share a relatively underpowered engine, but they differ dramatically in gross weight.
Gone are the days of lightweight economy cars that could be powered (with air conditioning) by a small engine.
Our Smarts have all the 'advantages' of modern cars - all of which add weight: full electronics and servos (door locks, windows, convertable tops), ABS (sensors, wiring), emission controls (sensors, catalytic converters), safety (belts, air bags, sensors), fuel injection (electronics, sensors, injectors) etc, etc, etc.
Our 1000cc triples can barely manage the car as it is. Throw in the heavy taxation of a compressor and... well it's no wonder the Smart throws up its hands in despair!
Once the Koreans and Japanese begin to sell micro cars (or two seater city cars) in the US, and as economical forms of transportation, Daimler-Mercedes will have to seriously consider their marketing strategy: Econo-box (lightweight, no frills, exceptional gas mileage), or something else.
I look forward to other micro cars being sold here - and especially the stripped-down models like the good-old-days!
Even the most basic econobox offers better protection than my motorcycle! (Besides, if I were ascairt, I wouldn't be driving a Smart or riding an RE Bullet.)
Matt