He also mentions "1970s-era orange cloth seats"... which makes me wonder if he was even driving a U.S. 451 (unless he's confusing the red interior with orange coloring?).
I have decided all reviews are useless, since they usually mention the "automatic" transmission and they also test-drive it for a few hours. Every owner's report seems to say that, once you pass 1000 miles, the transmission (which is the #1 complaint point) shifts much nicer (mainly because you become accustomed to it, and you burnish the clutch plate). So, when I read the words "jerky transmission", I usually zone out from that point onward...