Dave Shembri recently commented on the question of the use of less than premium fuel. His comments:
"There has been some confusion regarding the recommended use of premium fuel which I want to help clarify. As many of you have noted the smart fortwo was engeneered to run on premium fuel (91 octane or higher) to provide the best performance and fuel economy. However, in limited and temporary situations, the smart fortwo can run on regular fuel. The owners manual says that if premium fuel isn't available when filling up, drivers can use partial tanks of regular fuel until premium becomes available. You should also try to drive more conservatively if using regular fuel-stressing the car while using regular fuel can negatively affect the car's durability and performance. Again, to be clear, using premium fuel best protects your car from damage to the engine and catalytic converter."