The Big Star Diner on Bainbridge Island (which was featured on a Food Network show, "Diners, Drive Inns and Dives") is now open under new management.
I have read both good and bad reviews, but I think it would be worth the trip to get 4, 5 7, 10, whatever smarts together and make the trip. Push the ferry dudes for two for one pricing, ride over, eat, wander around and come back. Whatever the food is really like, I think it would be a worth the trip. Maybe leave Seattle about 12 or 1 on a Saturday or Sunday afternoon?
Anyone else?