If you got the leads to one speaker reversed, the sound will be out of phase. They'll work, but being out of phase more or less destroys imaging and can cancel some sounds out. It just doesn't sound 'right' and you'll probably feel the overall volume isn't what it should be. If you suspect this is the case, reverse the leads on one of the speakers. The difference should be obvious.
EDIT: I am inclined to think you have not got a phasing problem because you say the bass sounds fine. What mades you suspect you might have them reversed?