Thanks for the help with the multiple #DIV/0! entries. As for cumulative mileage, I used the IF function:
=AVERAGE(IF(F2:F30<>0,F2:F30,""))
Column F is my tank by tank mileage, and I figured 29 entries should at least start me off. With this setup, it ignores any zero/nothing entry.
Thank you for all your inputs! I now have an impartial and accurate fuel log. Well, as accurate as the first click at a gas station will allow.