Join Date: Dec 2007
Thanked 486 Times in 356 Posts
Mentioned: 4 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1208 Post(s)
Coupe top vs. cabriolet top
Exactly as MB DNA stated.
I have a few additional comments, having first had two gas coupes, and now a Cabrio ED.
The Cabrio only seems noisier to me when the top is up. When it's open, it seems quiet, even on the freeway.
I learned that top-up wind noise is reduced significantly if you had previously closed the top while at a standstill rather than at speed. It might seal better that way?
Anyway, prior to buying it, I thought the extra noise might be an issue… but it's not a deal-breaker.
I'm fair-skinned, and need to avoid strong daytime sun. So I thought I wouldn't get much value from the Cabrio. Wrong! If it's hot outside, I still crack open the roof by several inches, giving a nice quiet airflow without baking me in the process. The extra draft created by cracking the roof just a few inches is amazing, and really reduces AC usage on warmer days. The roof is a lot more versatile than you might anticipate. In the early morning, late afternoon, and evening, the top always goes down. I never bother to remove the side rails.
With the top down, your rearward visibility is limited to about one-third of the upper portion of your cabin rearview mirror. I had thought this might be a problem, but it's not. If I need to back out of a parking situation and need better visibility, I just raise the roof to its first position so that the rear window is fully usable. When the top is up, there's never a problem.
I wondered if I might miss the coupe's panoramic roof, but I don't. The cabin is so tall, and there's so much glass already that it doesn't make it seem dark inside the Cabrio. Actually, it may stay a little cooler with the top up, which is important to me since I often have a canine companion riding shotgun. On the same subject of staying cool, I do like the Cabrio because I can leave the top cracked open in parking lots which keeps hot air from building up inside as much.
Because the Cabrio is tall AND has side rails, I don't worry as much about vandalism and security as I used to when I had low sports cars. Somebody couldn't slash the Cabrio top and simply reach in quickly to unlock it or grab something.
The Cabrio roof is very nicely finished in/out. At the rear, the lift-up feature of the window for loading really gives you excellent access. Overstuffed grocery bags slide right in with no problem! And I suppose, in theory, that you could load even more big/tall stuff (than in the coupe) if you were to put the Cabrio top down. And you could also load longer items by raising the rear window into its 'fixed raised' position, unlike the coupe which would require tying down the glass to do the same feat.
So far, the benefits of a Cabrio outweigh any downside, but they're both still great options!