Smart Car of America Forum banner
1 - 18 of 18 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
771 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Learned that on our 2017 453 with the stick shift has an interesting throttle response while in neutral. Doing my monthly start up of the 453 in it’s winter home (the garage) I found that if you tromp on the throttle while in neutral the tachometer tops out at around 4,000 and will not go past that level. I guess the computer limits revs in that state of neutral . It’s business as usual when driving , all the way to red line .
 

· Super Moderator
Joined
·
18,158 Posts
The pedal programmer is probably overriding the factory neutral rev limit. Most modern cars (with exceptions for oddballs like the Nissan Sentra) have a neutral rev limiter so you can't sit there in neutral or park banging off redline.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
9,769 Posts
…the ECU had the limiters removed…
…I also run a Split Second piggy back fuel/timing computer for the hair dryer…

…I’m starting to believe that the rpm nannie comes to play when the TPS gets out of limits while in N/P


Jetfuel…just a hunch
 

· Registered
Joined
·
36 Posts
...with the original (2007) programming of the TCU I was able to trick it out by revving over 2K and take it from N to 1 while holding the revs up and flooring the accelerator - I was able to rev up to the redline.

After changing to a newer program version for earlier shift points, this trick was not possible any more.

I think the rev nanny is located in the TCU - have you try to kill it there?

greetings
Marc
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,585 Posts
I may be wrong, but my understanding is it’s an ECM software limit if the car is not in gear. Without a load, torsion on internal parts is different than when under normal conditions and stuff starts flexing. If parts are stressed beyond tolerances, it wouldn’t be difficult to start smashing parts together that shouldn’t.

Think of it like holding down the eraser end of a pencil firmly on a table and giving the other end a jolt. The free end of the pencil vibrates wildly, sometimes even to the point where it can break free of the end that’s being held against the table. Now wrap the pencil with duct tape. The change in load with a similar force causes a change in the vibration frequency - slower oscillations, less potential damage.

A bunch of years ago I had the pleasure of being present at during UL certification tests at a company I worked for. One of the tests clamps a part to an random oscillation table. The amplitude of the vibration remained constant due to the mechanical limits of the table, but the frequency was gradually increased until hitting the natural resonating frequency of the part. It was both shocking and spectacular to see the parts literally tear themselves apart at a particular frequency. It was almost if they had exploded. It was so cool to see I would have loved to become a UL certification engineer to break stuff like that for a living.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
9,769 Posts
…soom you may have a point…
…I thought about a load cell where voltage in and a couple of shunts will monitor torsional loads and changing resistance will prevent overloads…
… then I thought that the bean counters will have a final say on designs…
…they already had a way of monitoring at least motion…so…if no frequency from reluctor rings no rpm past a set point written into the program…

Jetfuel… I could be wrong too
 
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
Top