I think I may be able to explain the difference as to why some are posting the different batteries.
Normally these cars’ key takes a 2016 battery but with a little modding of the housing you can fit a 2025 battery (yes it’s thicker but the lifespan is a lot longer)
Did it on both my smarts keys and couldn’t be happier with the battery performance.
I also agree on a new battery being a dud straight out of the pack(been there before many times)