Smart Car of America Forum banner

1 - 6 of 6 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Hi I have an 2016 electric smart which requires a new body (it was damaged in an accident). I want swap the body with another body. Do i need a body from another ED vehicle or can I use another 2016 fortwo body?

thanks
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
912 Posts
If it is only the plastic panels that have been damaged, those can be easily swapped.

If it is the actual unibody - the "tridion" - the steel structural part of the body - then it's complicated.

Three part answer, "technical", "economics", "legality".

The "technical" part is that theoretically, the bodyshell is the bodyshell, everything that has anything to do with the powertrain just bolts to it. So, theoretically, there is nothing technically to stop someone from taking a gasoline powered smart and an electric one of the same chassis generation (451 or 453, NOT necessarily the model year) and swapping everything that makes it go. But I mean EVERYthing. Powertrain. Battery pack vs fuel tank. Wiring harness (and this means tearing the interior apart). Instruments. Some suspension parts. It is A LOT of labour. Two cars have to be pretty much fully disassembled and one reassembled (presumably the other one will be left as a pile of parts).

But that brings up "economics". These are low-value cars. Face it ... they are. You can get another one very cheaply. Surely it will be more economical to simply chuck away the broken one and buy another. Bear in mind that if you were to do the "swap" you will STILL be buying another car to do the swap with. Against the number of hours of labour that it will take to do this ... There's just no way it's worthwhile.

And then there's "legality". If you have a car that "needs a new body" ... What's the insurance say about this? What's the registration status? If it's legally written off, there's no point saving it. Chuck it away and buy another one.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
Hi Gofaster, thanks for the reply.

so yes it is the tridion body (mine was hit in in the rear left corner, and classified/sold as a salvage/ rebuild-able.

I am more interested in the technical rather than legal and economic, as legally I am allowed to amalgamate two vehicles and my ED is classified as a rebuild-able car, and economics is I have the ED vehicle already and have sourced a possible tridion. So it comes down to are the two tridion's the same 451 vs 453. '

Is there an easy way to identify a them or is it easier to take both vin numbers to the dealer?
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
11,309 Posts
The 451 vs he 453 are two completely different vehicles. Just the size is not the same and the body parts (fenders, doors etc) are not even close to the same thing.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,947 Posts
2016 ED was a C451 body. 2016 gasser uses a C453 body. So you’d need a 2015 or older, to 2008, gas car body... (I think).
 
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
Top